Tips for Dealing with Disputes Between Tenants

This is a common for scenario for many a Tampa property manager. You get a phone call from tenant A. She’s fed up with tenant B for myriad of reasons. His dog howls at all hours of the night, he argues with his girlfriend, and he smokes cigars with his buddies until 3 in the morning. Tenant B feels that tenant A is being less than truthful about these allegations and adds that she slams doors at all hours of the night. They both feel quite passionate in their point of view and are looking for you to solve their problems.

Tenant disputes are major challenges for all Tampa property management companies, but they must be dealt with quickly. Conflicts can elevate fast and, in some cases, become violent. It never has to come to that. Use the following dispute resolutions tips to help your tenants resolve their issues.

Set the Ground Rules in the Lease

Among the many items that must be addressed in your lease, how conflicts will be resolved should be included. Decide here if you would like for tenants to handle the dispute first, when you should step in, and the procedure for reporting complaints. Also, report consequences for not following this policy and for harassing a fellow tenant. Be sure to address this section of the lease when you bring in a tenant and when a dispute arises.

When Mediating a Dispute, Be Impartial

A number of disputes are not going to be resolved between the conflicting parties. You are going to have to serve as the voice of reason in these cases. Always remain impartial when mediating a dispute, even if you favor one side over the other. Let both sides state their case and take time to make the best decision. Then explain to both parties what your decision will be and the specific reasons for that decision.

Document Everything

When you have made a decision in regards to a tenant dispute, write it down and make sure both parties sign the document. This is critical in the event that a tenant has an issue with how you handled the dispute and decides to take legal action.

For information about our Tampa property manager services, please call us at (813) 968-5665, or submit our proposal request form.


Our founder, William C. Spivey, is a man who believes in the power of people...



We are a family-owned and operated company built in the Tampa Bay Area by a working-class Tampa family.



In today’s day and age, technological advancements are occurring at a rapid rate. These developments...



At WPM, we understand the sensitivity and importance of a management transition. We will proactively work in...



  • Couldn’t have asked for better service. It’s NEVER this easy dealing with property management companies. Great Job! Thanks so much!

    Brent I.

  • Cody Glass from the accounting department was very helpful and professional with a lot of courtesy to help me to understand and set up a new payment process.

    Eric F.

  • I work with Wise on a regular basis, as the nature of our business requires quick turn around times. They are kind and helpful when you need something.

    Natasha A.

  • I have always received great service from Wise. Any time I need help someone always answers the phone and directs me to the right department.

    Elaine R.

  • My name is George Florence, I am the Board President of Villas of Northdale, and I have been a Board member for 5 years now. We have had perfect help from Wise Property Management.

    George F.

  • Wise Property Management is the quintessential image of a professional, organized, comprehensive, deligent and knowledgeable Property Management company.

    Kristy D., South Pointe HOA Vice President.

  • I have been working with Jeanie Hunter of Wise Property for several years now. She has handled all our Tampa Villas South association issues promptly and with great efficiency.

    Ken C., Tampa Villas South HOA Vice President.

  • Very easy to work with and everyone is friendly. We have worked with them for a very long time and love the experience. They take pride in their work and truly enjoy what they do.

    Joey V.

  • Contact Information

  • Community Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.